Some Americans Think Moving To Canada Will Solve All Their Problems. But Canada Has Its Own Issues

• Some Americans move to Canada in search of less polarized politics and reduced risk of gun violence.
• Two people who moved said they faced long waiting lists for healthcare and still-high housing costs.
• "Canada is one of the greatest countries in the world, but it’s no utopia," an immigration lawyer said.

Born in the South, Mahlena-Rae Johnson moved to Los Angeles after graduating from high school. She eventually found a partner and a community of people who made California feel like home.

Johnson, a 42-year-old Black woman, said she felt a turning point when Donald Trump beat Hillary Clinton in the 2016 US presidential election. She said she felt it laid bare profound political and ideological divisions within the nation, which resulted in a growing intolerance toward non-cisgendered Americans.

In 2018, she and her partner relocated to Canada, seeking what they perceived to be a more politically progressive and secure environment to raise their children.

"I watched videos of people who moved to Canada, and one man who had moved years ago said that he liked living in a place where he knew his country wasn’t constantly at war," Johnson told Business Insider. "It is overall a place where I feel safer with my family."

According to Google Trends, searches for "moving to Canada" tend to spike following polarizing events, such as the presidential debate between President Joe Biden and former President Donald Trump on June 27. After a disastrous performance in that debate, Biden stepped aside, making way for Vice President Kamala Harris to eventually become the Democratic nominee.

Similar spikes were observed during the 2016 presidential election, the bitter debate between Trump and Biden ahead of the 2020 presidential election, and the Supreme Court’s overturning of Roe v. Wade in 2022.

Searches for "moving to Canada" had already started to increase in the month leading up to Election Day 2024. They skyrocketed on Election Day and the day after, when Trump won the presidency, per Google Trends.

"Usually when there’s an election cycle, or when people don’t like who is elected, Americans in particular want to move to Canada," VisaPlace CEO Michael Niren, an immigration lawyer with more than 25 years of experience in Canadian migration, told BI.

Fewer Americans actually follow through on their internet dreams and make the move. According to immigration data from the Canadian government, 93,095 Americans were granted permanent residency from 2015 through the end of the third quarter of 2024.

The number of Americans granted permanent residence increased most years during that stretch. In 2015, 7,655 people got it; in 2023, 10,640 people did. 2021 saw the largest number: 11,955.

Two Americans who recently moved to Canada told BI they did so to escape polarized and divisive politics, seek better healthcare, and feel safer in their communities.

While they said their overall quality of life had improved, they found the grass wasn’t greener in every arena: There can be long waiting lists for medical care, and it’s very expensive to buy a home.

One mover said Canada’s schools were better, but its free healthcare was still flawed

Johnson, who primarily wanted to escape American politics, said she discovered some advantages of Canada’s schooling system once her children enrolled.

In LA, she said, "many of the schools are in trailers instead of actual buildings," but in Canada, "children can go to school and not worry about having a place that is safe or not being in an actual building."

Johnson said she and her family had also enjoyed Canada’s universal, publicly funded healthcare system, under which citizens and permanent residents get most medically necessary care and medications free or at a very low cost.

She added that there were some frustrations, including lengthy waiting periods for medical care. "During the pandemic, doctors couldn’t see patients as regularly and nonemergency procedures were postponed, so there’s a backlog," she said.

Niren, who has lived in both the US and Canada, voiced similar concerns. He said his own mother, who needs a hip replacement, was on a waiting list for 18 months.

"There are people who have to fly to other countries — including the United States — to get cancer treatment because it takes too long," he said. "In the US, you can get a specialist appointment in two days."

Niren also said Canadians paid elevated taxes to support such a comprehensive healthcare system.

"People call it free healthcare — it’s not free," he said. "It’s very expensive because you’re paying through the taxes."

An American found relief from the US’s violence and opioid crises in Canada

Chris Ouellet, 40, left Portland, Oregon, for Victoria, British Columbia, in 2020. It wasn’t his first-choice destination, he said, but he ended up finding the peace and safety he was looking for.

He and his partner had planned to move to Wellington, New Zealand, but were unable to because of pandemic border lockdowns. A lot of the characteristics Ouellet was looking for in New Zealand, he said, he found in British Columbia.

"We love the Pacific Northwest, and Canada is not far up the road," Ouellet told BI. "It’s very similar weather, and they have a lot of the things that we wanted and what we were looking for in New Zealand, which was a lower cost of education, socialized healthcare, and politics that weren’t so incredibly polarizing."

Ouellet, who works for the provincial government at the Ministry of Health in British Columbia, spoke glowingly of Portland but did point out the "pretty bad" violence and opioid crises he witnessed in the US overall. Before Portland, he and his partner lived in Chicago. The violence they would read about or see on their daily commutes prompted them to move west and eventually out of the country altogether, he said.

He hasn’t had the same worries in Canada.

"In British Columbia, the regulations for being able to own a gun are extremely tight," he said. "When you’re out in public, and you hear a noise, no one runs, no one checks over their shoulder, no one thinks that it could possibly be gun violence."

He added that there was still an opioid crisis in British Columbia but it wasn’t as striking as it was in Portland. Ouellet said that in the three years he’d lived in British Columbia, he’d seen one syringe on the ground, compared with Portland, where he said he might see dozens in one day.

Ouellet said that he had no regrets about moving to British Columbia but that Canada’s housing crisis had so far sidelined his dreams of homeownership.

"The house that we had in Portland was three bedrooms, 2 ½ baths. It was about 1,800 square feet, and we bought it for $265,000," he said. "You can’t find a place for that price here. Most condos are around $500,000 to $900,000. Single-family homes are almost a million."

As Niren said, "Canada is one of the greatest countries in the world, but it’s no utopia."

This story was originally published on December 5, 2023, and was updated on November 5, 2024.

Are you an American who moved to Canada? We want to hear from you. Reach out to the reporters, Alcynna Lloyd at alloyd@businessinsider.com and Jordan Pandy at jpandy@businessinsider.com, with your story.